Cite as Oster v. Bisalen,
7 FSM Intrm. 414 (Chk. S. Ct. Tr. 1996)

[7 FSM Intrm. 414]

and OSUPWANG RIKAT, on behalf of themselves
and all other persons similarly situated,


WILIPINAT BISALEN, in his official capacity as
Director of Treasury, and CHUUK STATE,

CSSC-CA-NO. 267-95


Richard H. Benson
Special Trial Court Justice

Decided:  March 14, 1996

For the Plaintiffs:          Midasy Aisek
                                       Micronesian Legal Services Corporation
                                       P.O. Box D
                                       Weno, Chuuk FM 96942

[7 FSM Intrm. 415]

For the Defendants:     Kachuo Eko
                                       Assistant Attorney General
                                       Office of the Chuuk Attorney General
                                       P.O. Box 189
                                       Weno, Chuuk FM 96942

*    *    *    *

Attorney, Trial Counselor and Client ) Disqualification of Counsel
     A trial counselor who is a member of a plaintiff class that is seeking money damages from the state has a conflict and cannot represent the state and will be allowed to withdraw.  Oster v. Bisalen, 7 FSM Intrm. 414, 415 (Chk. S. Ct. Tr. 1996).

*    *    *    *

RICHARD H. BENSON, Special Trial Court Justice:
     This case came before me on the motion of Mr. Kachuo Eko to withdraw as counsel for the defendants.  The plaintiffs filed their response to the motion.  On March 4, 1996, a conference on the record was held with the parties present, and the motion was granted.

     The plaintiffs in this case allege that they are employees of Chuuk State who have had allotments deducted from their paychecks by the defendants, but the defendants have failed to pay the amounts so deducted to the creditor allotees. The complaint asks the court to certify as a class all other Chuuk State employees similarly situated.

     Mr. Eko is a member of the class)that is, he is a Chuuk State employee who has had allotments taken out of his pay.  Those deductions, however, have not been delivered by the State to his creditors.

     Three of the named plaintiffs are prosecuting attorneys in the same office as Mr. Eko, the office of the Attorney General of Chuuk State.

     The Model Code of Professional Responsibility governs the ethical conduct of practitioners appearing before this court.  Truk State Bar R. 13(a).  A lawyer may refuse to represent a client when his financial interest may impair his independent professional judgment.  MCPR DR 5-101(A).  Such representation may be undertaken if the client consents after full disclosure by the lawyer of his interest in the case.  Id.  Whether this was done or could be done was not presented to me.

     The problem of Mr. Eko representing interests of the defendants which directly conflict with the claims of the three members of his law firm presents an ethical problem which cannot be consented to by the client.  It would be unethical for him to do so.  MCPR DR 5-101(A) & (B); ABA Opinion 296 (1959).  Mr. Eko's withdrawal is therefore proper.  MCPR DR 2-110(B)(2).

     It is therefore ordered that Kachuo Eko withdraw as lawyer for the defendants.

     It is further ordered that the defendants employ counsel who, by March 25, 1996, shall file and serve his or her notice of appearance.

[7 FSM Intrm. 416]

     It is further ordered that the answer filed by Mr. Eko on January 24, 1996 is stricken.
ems10vkhDefaultTokenIdnk TMe AppLexiconsnk PT t&{C9E37C15-DF92-4727-85D6-72E5EEB6995A}lf@AppL{C9Enk TP\boFilesxevk oDatafilevk(aDefaultTokenIdvk(DefaultTokenIdЏhbinX%1a%\Microsoft\Speech\Files\UserLexicons\SP_8DDBCDC53F34443D9E584222DB35AEC6.dat6nk \TȅnkPhoneConverters`HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Speech\PhoneConverters\Tokens\English%9|nk TcP ȅ@ RecognizersXHKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Speech\Recognizers\Tokens\MS-1033-61-DESKlf AppLAudiCurrȐPhonȑRecoVoicnk TȅVoicesMpHKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Speech\Voices\Tokens\LHMICHAELnk ,x8*ؔ N SQMClientvkNUserId{D510D602-9976-462B-48B8-FE74AC20D16F}`nk e_8*@ SystemCertificatesnk *(:R]CAhnk t.HP CertificatesX@0nk ̨8ycu(1381E139ACE7B6AA02A86E0D49ACA66AA3AC02ECvkyBlob9綪n IjOюAS7KCZMPFK){I8`t/?b7U*|?Fws Ew?Qpb 00 a+0  *H 0'1%0#UMicrosoft Internet Authority0 060421191104Z 090419235900Z010 &,dcom10 &,d microsoft10 &,dcorp10 &,dredmond1*0(U!Microsoft Secure Server Authority0"0  *H 0 )$bOJJ̉^~.wQ?0v!kY\_